Choosing the right rental car can make a huge difference to your Iceland adventure.
Pick a car that’s too small, and you might struggle on gravel roads or with luggage.
Choose one that’s bigger than you need, and you’ll spend more money on both the rental and fuel.
After several self-drive trips around Iceland—including driving the entire Ring Road in both summer and winter—we’ve learned that the best rental car depends entirely on when you’re visiting and where you’re planning to go.
In this guide, we’ll help you choose the perfect rental car for your Iceland itinerary.
Quick Guide
| Your Trip | Best Rental Car |
|---|---|
| Reykjavík city break | Economy car |
| Golden Circle | Economy or Compact |
| South Coast | Compact or SUV |
| Ring Road (Summer) | Compact or Mid-size SUV |
| Ring Road (Winter) | AWD SUV or 4×4 |
| Highlands (F-Roads) | 4×4 only |
| Families | Mid-size or Large SUV |
| Couples | Compact SUV |
Best Economy Car
Perfect For:
- Reykjavík
- Golden Circle
- South Coast
- Summer holidays
- Couples
If you’re sticking to Iceland’s main paved roads during summer, an economy car is often all you need.
Benefits include:
- Cheapest rental prices
- Better fuel economy
- Easy parking
- Comfortable for two people
Typical examples include:
- Toyota Aygo
- Kia Picanto
- Hyundai i10
These cars are ideal if you’re travelling on a budget and not planning to venture onto mountain roads.
Best Compact Car
Perfect For:
- One-week road trips
- Ring Road (Summer)
- Small families
Compact cars offer a little more luggage space and extra comfort for longer journeys.
Popular choices include:
- Toyota Yaris
- Volkswagen Polo
- Kia Ceed
For many visitors, this is the best balance between price and practicality.
Best SUV
Perfect For:
- Winter travel
- Ring Road
- Gravel roads
- Couples or families
If you’re visiting between October and April, we’d strongly recommend an SUV.
Advantages include:
- Higher driving position
- Better stability
- More luggage space
- Increased confidence in winter conditions
Common models include:
- Dacia Duster
- Kia Sportage
- Hyundai Tucson
- Toyota RAV4
We’ve driven SUVs in Iceland during winter and found the extra confidence well worth it.
Best 4×4
Perfect For:
- Highlands
- F-Roads
- Serious adventures
Planning to explore Landmannalaugar, Askja or other Highland destinations?
You’ll need a proper 4×4.
F-roads are only open seasonally, and standard 2WD cars are not permitted on them.
Popular options include:
- Toyota Land Cruiser
- Jeep Wrangler
- Toyota Hilux
Best Electric Car
Electric vehicles are becoming increasingly popular in Iceland.
They’re ideal if you’re:
- Staying around Reykjavík
- Driving the Golden Circle
- Following the Ring Road and planning charging stops
Blue Car Rental now offers a growing range of EVs, including models such as the Tesla Model 3, Tesla Model Y and Kia EV3.
Best Family Car
Travelling with children?
Look for:
- Large boot
- Comfortable rear seats
- Automatic gearbox
- Plenty of luggage space
Mid-size SUVs are usually the sweet spot for family road trips.
Summer vs Winter
Summer (May–September)
For most visitors:
✅ Economy
✅ Compact
✅ Small SUV
All work well if you’re sticking to the Ring Road and major attractions.
Winter (October–April)
Winter is different.
Roads can become:
- Snowy
- Icy
- Windy
We’d recommend an AWD SUV or 4×4 for extra confidence, particularly if you’re travelling outside Reykjavík.
Which Rental Company Do We Use?
After several trips to Iceland, we’ve consistently had excellent experiences with Blue Car Rental.
What we like most:
- Modern vehicles
- Online check-in
- Fast collection near Keflavík Airport
- Wide choice of vehicle types
- Transparent pricing
- Strong customer service
Their fleet ranges from compact city cars to large SUVs, electric vehicles and luxury models, making it easy to choose a vehicle that suits your trip.
🚗 Book your Blue Car Rental here (and support Icelandic Adventure):
https://www.bluecarrental.is/?affiliate=IcelandicAdventure
What About Campervans?
If you’re planning a week or more in Iceland, we’d seriously consider hiring a campervan instead.
We travelled around Iceland with CampEasy, and it completely transformed our road trip.
Having your accommodation with you gave us complete flexibility and allowed us to wake up somewhere different every morning.
Our readers also receive an exclusive FREE Easy Start Pack.
🚐 Book your CampEasy campervan here:
https://campeasy.com/?tap_a=107011-a856e5&tap_s=8902128-1989f0
Stay Connected
Driving around Iceland is much easier with reliable mobile data.
We constantly use our phones for:
- Google Maps
- Weather forecasts
- Road conditions
- Fuel stations
- Aurora forecasts
We always use Saily eSIM.
📱 Save 10% here:
https://go.saily.site/aff_c?offer_id=101&aff_id=15717
Our Top Tips
- Book as early as possible, especially for summer.
- Choose the car for your itinerary—not just your budget.
- If you’re visiting in winter, don’t be afraid to upgrade to an SUV.
- Check what insurance is included before booking.
- If you’re driving F-roads, make sure your vehicle is permitted to use them.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need a 4×4 in Iceland?
Not always.
If you’re travelling in summer and sticking to the Ring Road and major attractions, a 2WD car is usually enough.
If you’re visiting in winter or planning to drive F-roads, we’d recommend a 4×4 or AWD vehicle.
Is an automatic or manual better?
If you’re not comfortable driving a manual, choose an automatic.
You’ll be able to focus more on Iceland’s unique road conditions and incredible scenery.
What’s the best car for the Ring Road?
For most travellers:
- Summer: Compact car or mid-size SUV.
- Winter: AWD SUV.
Final Thoughts
The best rental car in Iceland isn’t necessarily the biggest or the most expensive—it’s the one that matches your travel plans.
For most visitors exploring the Ring Road, we’d recommend a compact SUV as the ideal balance of comfort, practicality and confidence in changing conditions.
And if you’re looking for a rental company we genuinely trust after multiple trips around Iceland, Blue Car Rental remains our top recommendation.
Choose the right vehicle, take your time, and enjoy one of the world’s greatest road trips.
Happy driving!
Leave a Reply